Sorry Zack but I don't agree so easily with your point of view. The issue of cross posting without a linkage, has been raised with increasing frequency over the last couple of months. We all know why we should post the link...

Either we value the assistance given by the members of this forum or we don't.

Personally I believe that, those who cross post do so for the primary reason that they are dis-satisfied with the progress of their post. In this case, Nader's post was difficult to understand, from either its intent or layout, before the workbook was provided. Maybe if it had been presented in a different layout, the responce may have been different.

I strongly believe that those who cross post without indicating a linkage should not be apologising the gunslinger ( ), but offer an apology to those members of the forum who have gone out of their way to assist.