you need to use the original code posted before, with just the small part i changed in place of the original
make sure to use the correct folder path
check the array is still correct immediately after redim preserve

post your entire code, as i do not see any reason, in any of the codes posted, why such a problem should be occurring
there are probably some errors in the suggested code, but they would cause errors to occur, not just wrong results, unless some inappropriate error handling