It seems you were missing the point that I was trying to make, so may I take this opportunity to refresh your attention to this matter.

when one posts a thread to the forum, we naturally are expecting to see a thread title and then followed by a description of the issue. The description normally includes what you are trying to achieve, what you may have done so far and an example of your workbook.

In post #1 you placed a title and a workbook but no description, then in post #3 a workbook but no description. Can you see that so far, no one would want to assist you given that we currently have no information as to what you are trying to achieve.

In post #4 you finally give us an insight on the situation, then indicate that you have solved the issue. Thats good, but for those reading this thread you haven't actually indicated how you solved the issue.

iFinally, we see ( in post #5)that you have posted this issue elsewhere, but failed to notify the forum here that you have done so. All right maybe you did so because you failed to get assistance here, but can you understand why you didn't receive assistance?

I remain very confident that we have many members here who would have been willing to assist you if only you had been a little more helpful in the first instance.