sorry, i just look this message, if use "For file_check = 1 To Workbooks.Count" , when it finish (close how many excel)then jump to other sub, it will cause how many close excel circle. like if it close three excel file. then when it finish, it will make three circle. but maybe it only error in my code, if you want to look, attach file is full file, you can refer it. sorry about my English not very well, maybe cause you confuse.